top of page
Search

Generative AI and human beings are in a boat. Who goes overboard?

Nov 11
5 min read

Updated: 3 days ago


I took part in a discussion at Satis 2026 alongside Gilles Daniel and Sebastien Cirade, chaired by Jean-Yves Le Moine: ‘AI and screenwriting: from assistance to narrative hegemony?’


I won't dwell here on what AI can or cannot do: whatever it doesn't know how to do, or cannot do today, it will very probably be able to do tomorrow. What I do think is essential, however, is to question the place it occupies when it is used to create a work of art.


When we write, the idea we think we have often takes on a different shape on the page from the one we had expected. Because it is through writing that we search for and explore the right expression of the story, carried by the precision of words and style. We also discover that we write like ourselves, in a style that might bear the vaguest resemblance to Joan Didion, when what we would have liked was to write like Jeffrey Eugenides. Because, in the creative process, we cannot do otherwise (even though, more often than not, we try at first) than be ourselves. The act of writing, then rereading and rewriting, and rereading again, sharpens our thinking, our story, its form... It reveals what we didn't quite know we were looking for, refines our feelings and sensations, and clarifies what we are trying to say and convey. First and foremost, it is a one-to-one encounter, even in collaborative art forms such as cinema. We first establish our own position, then confront and enrich it through other perspectives.


But what if a human being were to direct an AI, making countless iterations until the result was what they ‘wanted’, until it was convincing, even moving, perhaps even successful? Could they then be considered an artist? In my view, no.

Because what is created by AI begins with a prompt that seeks its form in the response, rather than in a sensitive inner life. That, for me, is where the fundamental divide lies: the first building block of the work comes from the machine.

(The prompt is not a first building block; it belongs to the realm of desire.)


Furthermore, AI is not one other, but a multitude of others, by virtue of the corpus it has digested (plundered), which it mixes algorithmically and probabilistically to create the illusion of originality, of a unique voice. This is very different from a human being who has read widely, because they have absorbed those works through the prism of their own history, experience and sensations. They may have loved obscure works and disliked others considered essential. They have judged them according to what they stirred in them, whereas AI recombines statistical patterns without any inner necessity. And in doing so, when it generates, it irons out human improbability, flashes of brilliance and poetry.

A pen cannot write, it suggests nothing; there is nothing between the person writing and the blank page. AI, on the other hand, makes suggestions, often with extraordinary conviction. And even if you reject what it proposes, what it has suggested has already defined a framework of thought that you did not establish yourself, because it seems to have a consciousness, even when you know it doesn't. What it does have is extraordinary processing power combined with a dizzying volume of data, which it recombines to answer you. That is far from insignificant; indeed, it is wonderful for many fields. But neither processing power nor data knows anything of emotions and sensations, which are the living matter of the artist, and their starting point.


Generative AI pulls the wool over our eyes, making us believe we are creators when all we are is prompters of a fantasy.


The process of thought at the heart of creation – built and dismantled, critical, free, uncertain and sensitive – requires time, space and effort, all of which generative AI throws out of balance. Finding a way to express the emotion behind a man's glimpse of a translucent, slightly damaged rose petal on a dirty pavement is no easy matter. But it is precisely in that impulse to explore, experiment, refine the words and the material that we become artists. It is the difficulty, the frustration, the ‘almost’, and sometimes the moment when we finally reach what we were looking for with absolute precision. It is also the pleasure, the physical sensation of having found it.


There is an effort involved in the act of creating, a desire to move from the inside out, to give voice to a thought that is still unclear, a need to put one's finger on something still hidden, something one senses is there and wants to bring to light. This effort, necessarily human, is worn down, displaced and distorted by generative AI.


Whether the artist is good or bad is of little concern to me here. What matters to me is the gesture itself, and the confrontation with what they are capable of doing. Their determination and intention to find, against all odds, the precise form of their thoughts and feelings, and to communicate them beyond themselves, by searching within.


It is true, of course, that AI can produce work that is received as being of equal quality to that of a human writer. AI can even write far better than many human beings. But then why deprive ourselves of it? Why go on defending human creativity by arguing that it is infinitely richer because it is more imperfect? And if a book pleases you and moves you, what does it matter if it was written by a machine, all the more so if it was supervised by a human being? What difference does it make?

I believe that is precisely where the real question lies.


Because I don't know about you, but I want to be moved, unsettled, touched by something living: by a mind in motion, by doubts, flaws, imperfections and flashes of brilliance. I don't want an imitation, however perfect it may be. I would rather have an imperfect human work than a synthetic one. I want someone to have addressed me. Someone. Flesh, nerves, blood and bone. I want our shared humanity to resonate, to engage in dialogue, to clash. I also want to remain human, defined by my imperfect thoughts and my attempts. And I don't want to become a commodity, or food for the machine. I want to stand on equal terms. I want to retain, protect and preserve my humanity, however mediocre it may be, because its impulse is alive and authentic.



_______________________

Déborah Braun / 90pages

Script consultant




_______________________


 
 

+336 61 35 85 85 

  • LinkedIn Déborah Braun

Cookies Policy

Legal Notice

Privacy Policy

Terms and conditions

logo de 90pages script consulting

90pages is a script consulting practice founded by Déborah Braun, a film editor and script consultant with 20+ years’ experience. She brings her experience of the film’s third writing to screenplay consultation in French and English.

©2026 by 90pages script consulting

bottom of page